The Star of Hope Foundation, established by the late American artist Robert Indiana, has put his former home on the market in Maine, despite his wishes for it to become a public art space.

Indiana, famous for his iconic “LOVE” series, moved to Vinalhaven in 1978 and lived in the Star of Hope until his death in 2018. His will stipulated that the building be transformed into a museum-quality art environment, yet the foundation now plans to sell it for philanthropic purposes.

The foundation’s managing director, Carole Martin, believes the sale will allow them to focus directly on supporting Maine’s arts community. However, critics argue that this decision goes against Indiana’s intent, with Kevin Lipson of Venable law firm calling it a ‘remarkable repudiation’ of the artist’s testamentary wishes.

Marjorie Stratton, Vinalhaven’s town manager, who knew Indiana, expressed sadness over the decision, stating that the building was intended for art, education, and research. The current state of the property, with peeling paint and exposed framing, highlights the challenges of restoration.

Not all are against the move, with Elaine Crossman, who owns a motel and gallery in town, hopeful that a new owner might bring the building back to active use.